Pope Francis Resignation Rumors: What's True & What's Not
Is Pope Francis on the verge of resignation, or are the rumors a misconstrued whisper in the vast halls of the Vatican? Despite persistent speculation fueled by health concerns and historical precedent, the Pope himself has repeatedly and unequivocally stated his intention to remain in office, a declaration reinforced by his recent actions and pronouncements.
The echoes of Benedict XVI's resignation in 2013, the first in nearly six centuries, continue to resonate through the Catholic Church. This precedent has, understandably, amplified scrutiny of Pope Francis, particularly in the context of his age and recent health setbacks. Images of people gathering in Plaza Constitucion in Buenos Aires, Argentina, on February 24, 2025, to pray for his health and speedy recovery, serve as a poignant reminder of the global concern surrounding his well-being.
| Full Name | Jorge Mario Bergoglio |
| Born | December 17, 1936 (age 87) in Buenos Aires, Argentina |
| Nationality | Argentine |
| Education | Master's degree in Chemistry, Philosophy, and Literature |
| Ordained | December 13, 1969 |
| Episcopal Ordination | June 28, 1992 |
| Created Cardinal | February 21, 2001, by Pope John Paul II |
| Elected Pope | March 13, 2013 |
| Predecessor | Pope Benedict XVI |
| Motto | Miserando atque eligendo (Having mercy, he called him) |
| Significant Works/Actions |
|
| Controversies |
|
| Official Website | Vatican Official Website |
Rumors, often amplified by social media, have suggested that Pope Francis might be considering stepping down. A post shared on X (formerly Twitter) claimed he would resign due to health issues, however, these claims have been consistently debunked. Vatican sources, and the Pope himself, have repeatedly denied these reports. The Vatican has not made any announcements regarding the Pope's resignation, and the succession process within the Church dictates that a new Pope is elected by the College of Cardinals, not appointed by the current Pontiff.
Pope Francis, in his weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square on Wednesday, March 13, 2024, and in various other public appearances, has reiterated his commitment to his role. In a recent autobiography, "Life: My Story Through History," published on Tuesday, he firmly stated that he has "no plans to resign" and is not suffering from any health problems that would necessitate such a decision. He also mentioned in the memoir that he still has many projects to bring to fruition.
The Pope's recent hospitalization, following surgery on July 4 to remove part of his colon, has unfortunately fueled speculation. However, the timing of this procedure and the ensuing recovery period is a factor in amplifying the rumors. The fact that the Pope has delegated some responsibilities to cardinals while recovering from pneumonia has further raised questions among some, but these actions are common practice during periods of recovery and do not necessarily indicate any intention to resign.
A potential explanation for the confusing reports might lie in mistranslations of Italian statements into English. The nuances of language and the interpretations of statements can sometimes be misconstrued, leading to inaccurate reporting. For instance, Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi, the former head of the Vaticans department of cultural affairs, raised the possibility of resignation due to ill health, but this was an opinion and not an announcement or confirmation.
Pope Francis has been consistent in his pronouncements about his plans. On August 24, 2021, Luis Badilla reported that Pope Francis had no intention of resigning due to ill health. This was reiterated on December 13, 2023, when he declared, as reported by Vatican News, that he had "no intention of resigning."
The Pope's statements on the matter are clear. In the past, he has said he would resign if he were to become medically incapacitated. In the new interview he revealed that he has already signed his resignation letter to be used in the event of him becoming impaired. According to Pope Francis, there are no conditions for a resignation unless a serious physical impediment arises. In such an instance, a letter of resignation, deposited in the Secretariat of State and signed at the beginning of his pontificate, would be applicable. However, he has also said that it is the Pope's responsibility to "judge" if he is fit for his role. This points to the immense weight the Pope gives to his own health when considering resignation.
Pope Francis's decision to praise Benedict XVI's courage and humility in resigning over the course of their decade living together in the Vatican provides further context. He acknowledged that Benedict XVI had opened the door. The implication is not that this sets a precedent for Francis to necessarily follow, but rather that he acknowledges the possibility and respects the choice of his predecessor. The act of signing a resignation letter, to be used only if he is no longer able to fulfill the duties of his office, demonstrates his pragmatism and understanding of the demands of the papacy.
The concerns raised by some individuals, such as Cardinal Burke, highlight the broader theological and ideological landscape within the Catholic Church. Cardinal Burke, a vocal critic of Pope Francis's more progressive approaches, strongly opposes allowing divorced and remarried Catholics to receive the Eucharist. His contrasting views underscore the complex dynamics at play within the Church, but do not necessarily influence the Pope's decisions regarding his own position.
The ongoing speculation surrounding Pope Francis's health and potential resignation is an example of the tension between privacy and the public nature of the papacy. The world watches with concern, hoping for a speedy recovery and, more broadly, for continued guidance from the head of the Catholic Church. The Popes consistent messaging, however, suggests that he intends to remain in office, despite the challenges he faces, and to continue his work on the various projects he has initiated.
